FANDOM


  • NerdyNyanmurai
    NerdyNyanmurai closed this thread because:
    Opposed
    04:48, October 27, 2017

    So why do we separate this and this? It's all the same PvZ universe, so it's kinda weird how we would separate the same thing appearing in 2 different games. Why can't there just be one Peashooter page that looks like this:

    In Plants vs. Zombies

    Peashooter's appearance in PvZ shoots peas.

    In Plants vs. Zombies 2: It's About Time

    This appearance of Peashooter can use Plant Food and upgrade up to level 20.

    In Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare 2

    And so on...

    Why can't we just create sections explaining how that plant/zombie/item/mini-game acts in that particular game and have 1 page with it all? This would also clear up cross-game genders, of how it never mentions Umbrella Leaf's gender in PvZ, but clearly says she's female in PvZH.

    Symbol thumbs upSupport
    Merge all articles and create sections for the way that thing acts

    or

    Symbol thumbs downOppose
    Keep it the way it is
    Note: In order to be able to vote on mainspace related voting threads, you need at least 25 mainspace edits and you must have been on the wiki for two weeks. For any other topic, you must have been on the wiki for four weeks. If you do not follow these rules your vote will be disqualified. If you do it repeatedly, you will be given a forum warning. Thank you.
    To show your stance, please type {{Support|reason}}, {{Neutral|reason}}, or {{Oppose|reason}}. The reason must be stated behind the | in order to not be disqualified.
      Loading editor
    • Is this a vote or a discussion?

        Loading editor
    • I'm not sure what you mean.

      Although, what I mean by that is that I've wanted to merge all pages with the same names together for a while now (even before I had an account). I think we should have multiple sections on the same page of how that thing acts in the different games it appears in. \

      So I guess you could call it a vote. 

        Loading editor
    • Well, since you posted this in the wiki management branch, I'm assuming that you want to make this change. And there usually three types of threads; a voting thread, where support/oppose/etc. templates are used, choice vote threads, where choice templates are used, and discussion ones, where people just discuss about a change. Which variant is this one?

        Loading editor
    • Voting thread. 

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo
      Peashooter Winmo removed this reply because:
      Found out how to do it
      19:11, October 23, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • I actually know a theory (and support it) that many of mentioned PvZ games/comics/etc take place in different universes, because it explains different backstory of Citron in PvZ2, PvZH and PvZGW2, storyline inconsistency in all franchises and how comic books have all different human beings while most other stuff only has Crazy Dave and presumably the player himself

      But either way,

      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Sounds good on paper, but just look at Peashooter's page. Now look at Peashooter's page for another game. Now look at Peashooter's page for yet another game. All these pages are already big enough. If you merge them all into a single page it will bloat to indescribable sizes (I'm exaggerating here, but you get the point).
        Loading editor
    • Mr. Boss-inator wrote:
      I actually know a theory (and support it) that many of mentioned PvZ games/comics/etc take place in different universes, because it explains different backstory of Citron in PvZ2, PvZH and PvZGW2, storyline inconsistency in all franchises and how comic books have all different human beings while most other stuff only has Crazy Dave and presumably the player himself

      But either way,

      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Sounds good on paper, but just look at Peashooter's page. Now look at Peashooter's page for another game. Now look at Peashooter's page for yet another game. All these pages are already big enough. If you merge them all into a single page it will bloat to indescribable sizes (I'm exaggerating here, but you get the point).

      I see what you mean. But I think the humans in the comics and PvZA have just evacuated to somewhere else during the zombie apocalypse in all gthe other games. And Citron's backstory didn't change. He faught zombies in the future, but when Penny arrived, he joined the team and traveled through time. Then after PvZ2, he went back to the future to fight the last of the zombies, but then an Imp stole a z-mech and went to the past, while Citron was hired to go back to the past and hunt him down before he destroys the plants from the past. This is just what I think, but I think it's the same Citron. 

        Loading editor
    • Also, isn't there a template to hide and show large sections of info?

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      Mr. Boss-inator wrote:
      I actually know a theory (and support it) that many of mentioned PvZ games/comics/etc take place in different universes, because it explains different backstory of Citron in PvZ2, PvZH and PvZGW2, storyline inconsistency in all franchises and how comic books have all different human beings while most other stuff only has Crazy Dave and presumably the player himselfBut either way,
      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Sounds good on paper, but just look at Peashooter's page. Now look at Peashooter's page for another game. Now look at Peashooter's page for yet another game. All these pages are already big enough. If you merge them all into a single page it will bloat to indescribable sizes (I'm exaggerating here, but you get the point).
      I see what you mean. But I think the humans in the comics and PvZA have just evacuated to somewhere else during the zombie apocalypse in all gthe other games. And Citron's backstory didn't change. He faught zombies in the future, but when Penny arrived, he joined the team and traveled through time. Then after PvZ2, he went back to the future to fight the last of the zombies, but then an Imp stole a z-mech and went to the past, while Citron was hired to go back to the past and hunt him down before he destroys the plants from the past. This is just what I think, but I think it's the same Citron. 

      https://www.youtube.com/user/SadPandarenGames/videos just watch this guy, I'm bad at retelling :P

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      Also, isn't there a template to hide and show large sections of info?

      There is, but do you imagine the effort needed to load all the content into the page? We've already separated galleries from regular pages, why do we have to pretty much revert our effort?

        Loading editor
    • >Be me

      >Not very active on the wiki

      >Sees highlighted post

      >Thinks it’s some kind of conspiracy theory

      >WhatTheHeck.jpg

      >It’s not

      >Actually a vote

      >ScrewIt.png

      >Is going to vote

      >Don’t have enough edits.

      >Wants to do something

      And that’s how this message was made

        Loading editor
    • Mr. Boss-inator wrote:
      Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      Also, isn't there a template to hide and show large sections of info?
      There is, but do you imagine the effort needed to load all the content into the page? We've already separated galleries from regular pages, why do we have to pretty much revert our effort?

      That's another thing, the galleries.

      Making multiple

      pages about

      the same thing

      is like

      separating

      this sentance 

      into 8

      lines. 

        Loading editor
    • what ya on about?

        Loading editor
    • Garden Warfare and the comics have absolutely no correlations between each other except for plants and zombies. For them to be in the same "universe" would be absurd.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      It would be way too cluttered. A lot of mainseries pages are already a giant mess, and separating by game and function is way more organized. Plus, some of the things you mentioned have conflicting canons, so they actually aren't the same universe.
        Loading editor
    • Well if we're voting

      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      While they are most likely in the same universe (except MAYBE the comics due to different plot, but that only implies for the 2nd story (and maybe the 1st one too) ) the gameplay is different, so we separate them. We still need to separate Cactus, Explode-o-nut, and Dandelion, and I will not be satisfied until at least the one that is completely different in PvZ1 and PvZ2 (aka Explode-o-nut]]) is separated.
        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:

      Mr. Boss-inator wrote:
      Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      Also, isn't there a template to hide and show large sections of info?
      There is, but do you imagine the effort needed to load all the content into the page? We've already separated galleries from regular pages, why do we have to pretty much revert our effort?

      That's another thing, the galleries. Making multiple pages about the same thing is like separating this sentance  into 8 lines. 

      Breaking up the pages helps to keep the bandwidth usage per page down, preventing long load times when you might only need one small part of a page. Say you just need to know a plant's Almanac entry, why would you want to load the entire image gallery if you just need the Almanac entry section?

        Loading editor
    • Starfruity wrote:
      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      It would be way too cluttered. A lot of mainseries pages are already a giant mess, and separating by game and function is way more organized. Plus, some of the things you mentioned have conflicting canons, so they actually aren't the same universe.

      How do they have conflicting canons?

        Loading editor
    • Lily8763cp wrote:
      Well if we're voting
      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      While they are most likely in the same universe (except MAYBE the comics due to different plot, but that only implies for the 2nd story (and maybe the 1st one too) ) the gameplay is different, so we separate them. We still need to separate Cactus, Explode-o-nut, and Dandelion, and I will not be satisfied until at least the one that is completely different in PvZ1 and PvZ2 (aka Explode-o-nut]]) is separated.

      According to your logic we might as well separate PvZ Peashooter from the PvZJttW Peashooter.

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      According to your logic we might as well separate PvZ Peashooter from the PvZJttW Peashooter. 

      What are at least three differences between PvZJttW's Peashooter and PvZ's Peashooter.

      I'm actually curious.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      The pages would be way too big and confusing
        Loading editor
    • Lily8763cp wrote:
      What are at least three differences between PvZJttW's Peashooter and PvZ's Peashooter.

      I'm actually curious.

      Exactly nothing, other than his name is in Chinese in JttW.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      It's really confusing. They're all different, have different abilities, stats, and designs. It'll get too cluttered, like many other people said.
        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      While I do agree that everything is in the same universe (with a few possible exceptions), this is an incredibly inconvenient and, in my opinion, unnecessary overhaul. The way we have things now is just fine, and people looking for information could usually care less for the subject's other appearances. The way we have it now makes it easier for people to find the info we need by separating the plants by function. In addition, reducing a page to a section is just absurd, both in act and in page size.
        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      The main purpose of why we seperated such pages like Peashooter's is because of the different ways they work in each game (and also, yes, because merging them all into one page would really overload it). Since Peashooter from PvZ1 and PvZ2 are so similar, they are merged. But in say PvZH or PvZGW, Peashooter is very different due to the different game mechanics in each game.


      I actually remember making a discussion like this ways back about the Zombots. It got declined for a similar reason this thread is...

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      It's not confirmed that it's all one universe, and I can see a few glaring exceptions to your claims that it is all one universe (comics, for example). Not only that, but having one page for cross-game entities is inconvenient in several ways. Also, characters in different games that act completely differently in those different games deserve their own pages.
        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      I miss voting threads. Anyways, while I'm sure everything is in the same universe, the games function way too differently to all be on one page. Ya catch my drift?
        Loading editor
    • Could we at least rename Peashooter (PvZ: GW) to "Peashooter/Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare"? Or something. I mean, he's the same plant. Maybe just say this is his appearance is Garden Warfare?

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      Could we at least rename Peashooter (PvZ: GW) to "Peashooter/Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare"? Or something. I mean, he's the same plant. Maybe just say this is his appearance is Garden Warfare? 

      No, because Garden Warfare is different from the main series, and different genres means different strategies. Saying that's his appearance in Garden Warfare is a waste of a page.

        Loading editor
    • ShroomstagramUser wrote:
      No, because Garden Warfare is different from the main series, and different genres means different strategies. Saying that's his appearance in Garden Warfare is a waste of a page.

      Exactly! It's a waste to make multiple pages of the same thing.

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      ShroomstagramUser wrote:
      Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      Exactly! It's a waste to make multiple pages of the same thing. 
      You didn't get my point at all, do you? If I have to clarify, you seemed to be implying to delete the whole contents of the page and keep the pages saying just "this is hiw GW appearance" which is a complete waste of article, because you've reserved an article for just one sentence and/or picture. 
        Loading editor
    • ShroomstagramUser wrote:
      You didn't get my point at all, do you? If I have to clarify, you seemed to be implying to delete the whole contents of the page and keep the pages saying just "this is hiw GW appearance" which is a complete waste of article, because you've reserved an article for just one sentence and/or picture. 

      Lol no. I mean copy and paste that entire article into a section on the Peashooter page.

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      Lol no. I mean copy and paste that entire article into a section on the Peashooter page. 

      So, do whatever the FNaF wiki does? The page will be way too large, mah boi.

        Loading editor
    • ShroomstagramUser wrote:
      So, do whatever the FNaF wiki does? The page will be way too large, mah boi.

      Just looked at the FNaF wiki. Looks exactly what I see in my head when combining pages of the same name here.

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      So, do whatever the FNaF wiki does? The page will be way too large, mah boi.
      Just looked at the FNaF wiki. Looks exactly what I see in my head when combining pages of the same name here. 

      </div> Do you realise how much unnecessary data is loaded every time such a page is opened? Imagine yourself a PvZ noob. You want to come to the wiki to learn more about a plant in the only game you're currently playing, so you need only the information on that. If you want more info, open more pages. But if you need only that, you'll realise that your mobile data has been wasted on the unnecessary info.

        Loading editor
    • Mobile data? Most people use computers. It's very hard to use a phone for a wiki, anyway.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Despite the fact that all PvZ games take place in the same universe, the games are different genres. PvZ, PvZA, PvZ2, and basically all the Chinese games are tower defence games, GW and GW2 are shooters, and PvZH is a card game. They're all different. It makes sense to have one page for each of those genres, because as I just said, they're all different.
        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote:
      Mobile data? Most people use computers. It's very hard to use a phone for a wiki, anyway.

      Because let's ditch mobile users completely and pretend they don't exist.

        Loading editor
    • EpicGamer23468 wrote:
      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Despite the fact that all PvZ games take place in the same universe, the games are different genres. PvZ, PvZA, PvZ2, and basically all the Chinese games are tower defence games, GW and GW2 are shooters, and PvZH is a card game. They're all different. It makes sense to have one page for each of those genres, because as I just said, they're all different.

      Not all Chinese games are TD. All Stars is turn based game.

        Loading editor
    • The Skarmy Goat wrote:

      EpicGamer23468 wrote:
      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Despite the fact that all PvZ games take place in the same universe, the games are different genres. PvZ, PvZA, PvZ2, and basically all the Chinese games are tower defence games, GW and GW2 are shooters, and PvZH is a card game. They're all different. It makes sense to have one page for each of those genres, because as I just said, they're all different.

      Not all Chinese games are TD. All Stars is turn based game.

      I said basically all. That slipped past my mind when I wrote it.

        Loading editor
    • Peashooter Winmo wrote: Mobile data? Most people use computers. It's very hard to use a phone for a wiki, anyway.

      News flash!

      • Some people have "Internet" with limited data. For example, people who spend money on a cheaper Internet plan that is limited to *some number of bytes in either MB/GB* (e.g. 10GB, 750MB). If ever people used up all the limited data, no internet for them until they have to pay again. "Mobile data" is an example to this.
        • Don't forget that wiki has its own "mobile web version" and an app (free to download to both iOS and Android) that people with smartphones and tablets that people use to use less data, which is useful for those who have Internet with limited data. There other ways to do so as well.
      • Some people have computers that are so slow and/or outdated to the point where a very large wiki article can crash the browser or even worse, crash the computer.

      Honestly, I wish that is officially confirmed as I thought this thread talks about it being canon so I could comment like "*gender rule intensifies*" but...

      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      It's not even confirmed to be canon as of the moment. Plus, based on Peashooter Winmo's comments as I made this message, it's data consuming to the point where it can either prevent access to those who have limited Internet data, slow and/or outdated computers, or even both.


      @Dicussion Mods

      Might as well add "[Vote]" on this thread's title to prevent users like me for confusing this as a "news" of something being canon.

        Loading editor
    • AWikiBoy521 wrote:

      @Dicussion Mods

      Might as well add "[Vote]" on this thread's title to prevent users like me for confusing this as a "news" of something being canon.

      Done and done.

        Loading editor
    • If This Were To Come To Realization (Which At The Moment Seems Impossible), I Belive Different Categories On Each Page Would Be A Necessity, And Possibly Even Requiring Seperate Galleries, Effectively Making Each Page A Compilation Of All Others, Yet Still Seperated As Much As They Used To Be, Since Of The Disambiguation Pages Linking Them All Together Currently.

        Loading editor
    • Appledirt wrote: If This Were To Come To Realization (Which At The Moment Seems Impossible), I Belive Different Categories On Each Page Would Be A Necessity, And Possibly Even Requiring Seperate Galleries, Effectively Making Each Page A Compilation Of All Others, Yet Still Seperated As Much As They Used To Be, Since Of The Disambiguation Pages Linking Them All Together Currently.

      Each (re)incarnation does have a different page, and they do have separate galleries.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      We decided to separate the pages because the genres of the games are far different. There will be many sub-sections in strategies, upgrades, gallery, and trivia. The infoboxes and categories will be very messy if every game genre is put into a single page. It's acceptable to put similar games (PvZ1 and PvZ2) together, but for the others, sorry, they are too different.
        Loading editor
    • Someone456 wrote:

      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      We decided to separate the pages because the genres of the games are far different. There will be many sub-sections in strategies, upgrades, gallery, and trivia. The infoboxes and categories will be very messy if every game genre is put into a single page. It's acceptable to put similar games (PvZ1 and PvZ2) together, but for the others, sorry, they are too different.

      That's the idea I'm trying to put across too. Not all PvZ games are the same genre. As I said in my post, PvZ, PvZA, PvZ2, and basically all of the Chinese games (except All Stars, which is an RPG) are tower defence, GW and GW2 are shooters, and PvZH is a card game. Three (four if you count All Stars) totally different genres. I didn't mean to waffle on for so long. Basically, what I'm saying is that they're different sorts of games, and having them all on the same page would make the pages really messy.

        Loading editor
    • EpicGamer23468 wrote:

      Appledirt wrote: If This Were To Come To Realization (Which At The Moment Seems Impossible), I Belive Different Categories On Each Page Would Be A Necessity, And Possibly Even Requiring Seperate Galleries, Effectively Making Each Page A Compilation Of All Others, Yet Still Seperated As Much As They Used To Be, Since Of The Disambiguation Pages Linking Them All Together Currently.

      Each (re)incarnation does have a different page, and they do have separate galleries.

      Nice Pun ;)

        Loading editor
    • Appledirt wrote:

      EpicGamer23468 wrote:

      Appledirt wrote: If This Were To Come To Realization (Which At The Moment Seems Impossible), I Belive Different Categories On Each Page Would Be A Necessity, And Possibly Even Requiring Seperate Galleries, Effectively Making Each Page A Compilation Of All Others, Yet Still Seperated As Much As They Used To Be, Since Of The Disambiguation Pages Linking Them All Together Currently.

      Each (re)incarnation does have a different page, and they do have separate galleries.

      Nice Pun ;)

      Thanks!

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      These page variants of existing plants are meant to organize, there's no point in separating them, it makes accessing content a lot easier. We even have disambiguation pages for people like you who don't understand what's what. I'm sorry for the disrespectful attitude, but you're suggesting to remove one of the very strings that control a large majority of pages, and I can't help to say how stupid that sounds on paper.

      The amount of information in almost every variant of Peashooter in every Plants vs. Zombies page in 1 page would be huge, and we would probably need to degrade information quality to make the information more organized, and if we keep them all merged at once, it's going to make the pages messy and makes the disambiguation pages useless. You're going to cause the deletion of so many pages.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Do you want a cluttered page? Pvz 1 page is for main series. Gw is for Gw. Heroes is for Heroes. Anything bigger just crowds the page.
        Loading editor
    • I might as well just unfollow this now, since it's just the same statement, but by different users and using different words.

        Loading editor
    • ^^^

        Loading editor
    • Marcia Aeris
      Marcia Aeris removed this reply because:
      Sock
      23:57, October 24, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • nah man

      Symbol thumbs downOppose



      but it would be cool if there were plants and zombies that could travel through universes...

        Loading editor
    • BrandonPVZMaster wrote: nah man

      Symbol thumbs downOppose



      but it would be cool if there were plants and zombies that could travel through universes...

      Plants-Vs-ZombiesDisqualified vote
      Invalid reason
        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downSymbol thumbs downAbsolute Oppose
      You can't play a tower defense like a CCG, play a FPS like a RPG so why?


      p/s: It's confirmed, you 100% lost the duel with everyone now.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Just because it’s all the same thing, doesn’t mean they should all be crammed into one page. It would take up way to much space and would cause some lag on a mobile device.


      HOWEVER.

      I’m not sure if other wikis do this but

      You know that tab thing Winmo was going on about?

      Well we can do that, but instead of going to different sections of the same page, it’s just a LINK to one of it’s counterparts.

      I actually got this idea from the My Singing Monsters Wiki; [[1]]<—� an example of separating pages

        Loading editor
    • Pinacoin wrote:

      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Just because it’s all the same thing, doesn’t mean they should all be crammed into one page. It would take up way to much space and would cause some lag on a mobile device.


      HOWEVER.

      I’m not sure if other wikis do this but

      You know that tab thing Winmo was going on about?

      Well we can do that, but instead of going to different sections of the same page, it’s just a LINK to one of it’s counterparts.

      I actually got this idea from the My Singing Monsters Wiki; [[1]]<—� an example of separating pages

      Interesting. Maybe we could do that.

        Loading editor
    • Pinacoin wrote:
      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Just because it’s all the same thing, doesn’t mean they should all be crammed into one page. It would take up way to much space and would cause some lag on a mobile device.

      HOWEVER.

      I’m not sure if other wikis do this but

      You know that tab thing Winmo was going on about?

      Well we can do that, but instead of going to different sections of the same page, it’s just a LINK to one of it’s counterparts.

      I actually got this idea from the My Singing Monsters Wiki; [[1]]<—� an example of separating pages

      Actually, I think we already have something like that, but for the PvZAS Adventure levels. A great idea, but if we are going to do that, we'll have to get rid of the disambiguation pages. That'll take quite some time.

        Loading editor
    • MyNameIsMyName wrote:

      Pinacoin wrote:
      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Just because it’s all the same thing, doesn’t mean they should all be crammed into one page. It would take up way to much space and would cause some lag on a mobile device.

      HOWEVER.

      I’m not sure if other wikis do this but

      You know that tab thing Winmo was going on about?

      Well we can do that, but instead of going to different sections of the same page, it’s just a LINK to one of it’s counterparts.

      I actually got this idea from the My Singing Monsters Wiki; [[1]]<—� an example of separating pages

      Actually, I think we already have something like that, but for the PvZAS Adventure levels. A great idea, but if we are going to do that, we'll have to get rid of the disambiguation pages. That'll take quite some time.

      Yeah, that would take a while, having to find and delete every disambiguation page.

        Loading editor
    • I did it for the PvZAS Adventure level just because it's the exact same level, just with different modes. PvZ2C levels are about to be done the same, but ended up with the original tabber as the Hard Mode doesn't have much info.

      About this, using tabbers for this can be a good idea (but plz make it in the style like that MSM example, the ones in the levels are just for level modes). We can state as "Main", [insert game here], and an "Others" which leads to the disambiguation page if needed, along with keeping some of the italic notes at the top of the page. I'm not gonna vote as I don't entirely agree with this, as it takes time, but still.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Holy walls of text, this would create! In all seriousness, this is pretty complicated and kinda pointless. There's a reason these pages are separated- because each of these pages summarize what they do in that game. For example, Peashooter in PvZ and PvZ2 is way different from the Garden Warfare one. The only reason we put together the PvZ and PvZ2 incarnations of the plants and zombies is because they function the same (unless we are talking about something like Explode-O-Nut or All Star Zombie. These would make the pages extremely long, and tough to keep organized. Also, why would we ever consider some of those universes separate? I mean, the comics I understand, but Use Your Brains EDU and PvZ Stickers? Seriously? I can see where this could work, but the cons definitely outweigh the pros.

        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      That would clunk up pages and it would not be efficient at all.
        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Pages like Peashooter and Sunflower would be several essays long. Unnecessarily so. It's fine the way it is.
        Loading editor
    • //Should we just close this? It's clear Oppose won.

        Loading editor
    • IloveLuigi wrote: //Should we just close this? It's clear Oppose won.

      Indeed

        Loading editor
    • //Not yet. There's no rule state that you can just close this early unless you reach 25 Opposes.

        Loading editor
    • ThisUserLikesOreo
      ThisUserLikesOreo removed this reply because:
      Disq
      04:30, October 26, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • 6 left

        Loading editor
    • ThisUserLikesOreo
      ThisUserLikesOreo removed this reply because:
      ?
      04:30, October 26, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • Zombiecrab wrote:
      Twisted melon wrote:
      OPPOSE

      just stick with the time and space thing that we shown

      Ummmm...

      1st. dont ask and 2nd. idk how to the the oppose thing

        Loading editor
    • Twisted melon wrote:
      Zombiecrab wrote:
      Twisted melon wrote:
      OPPOSE

      just stick with the time and space thing that we shown

      Ummmm...
      1st. dont ask and 2nd. idk how to the the oppose thing

      YOU CAN NOT VOTE CAUSE U NO HAVE 25+ MS EDITS!!

      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      Anyway, having all counterparts in one page is too cluttered , is a big waste of space and is messed up due to different gameplay systems (IDK how you can have strategy about a card game and a Shooter in one page) . It make it hard for new users to edit due to the fact you can't use visual editor ( tabber ) and they do not know coding stuff easily, basically making the wiki's MS activity really slow
        Loading editor
    • Twisted melon wrote:

      Symbol thumbs downOppose
      just stick with the time and space thing that we shown
      Plants-Vs-ZombiesDisqualified vote
      Not enough mainspace edits
        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      We don't separate them based on continuity, which is not something PvZ really goes into. (I mean, how come Spikeweed is brown and green?) We separate them based on function. Doing otherwise would be trying to compare different genres of games. That said, I would be willing to do something like, say, use the Peashooter article to discuss the plant in general while splitting up the articles per game.
        Loading editor
    • Symbol thumbs downOppose
      The pages are all separated because the games have different genres. Imagine you want to find information about GW Peashooter and you just end up finding PvZH Peashooter. They're just the same plant sorted into different genres. It;s much easier finding Peashooter on separate pages.reason
        Loading editor
    • Three days have passed since this vote was submitted, and all votes were on the opposing side.

        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.