Board Thread:Wiki management/@comment-26520884-20160401212126/@comment-24760547-20160402213106

Brainulator9 wrote: Let me explain myself further:
 * It's better to have a concise title over a title that is needlessly bulky.
 * Newcomers will just click on the damn article to find that it's the wrong one, so the disambiguation serves to fix that.
 * Cleanup for Special:WantedPages to look for actual errors.
 * If Wall-Nut redirects to Wall-Nut (PvZH), then people with bad grammar will still link to the Heroes version when they mean to link to the main series version.
 * Double standards with pages like Tallnut, Snap Dragon, and Jalapeño versus Tall-nut, Snapdragon, and Jalapeno.

1. But the title is confusing, so even if it's short, it doesn't necessarily work.

2. Some people think that isn't the case.

3. (I didn't actually know that existed, so I'ma just skip that bullet point).

4. Then we don't have it redirect to the Heroes page.

5. We can change those too!

Now don't get me wrong, I understand what you're saying, but it's (apparantly) confusing people, and we need to make changes that cater to helping as many people as possible get information. And we don't always have to do what Wikipedia does. Saying whatever they do is "right" or "wrong" is kinda dogmatic.