Board Thread:Wiki management/@comment-3398859-20151130222234

Okay, I know that we have discussed this several times, but hear me out.

Literally the only reason I see to keep PvZ1 and PvZ2 Cactus on the same page is that they are "the same character".

So... are we treating plants like characters or species here? If they are species, then obviously all merging/separation rules state that we should have Cactus on separate pages.

If they are characters, we should use the genders each plant is given in the Almanac on pages, like we do with zombies.

Sure, there are some that can be debated like Dandelion, who frequently is named with different pronouns, but I have come to a proposal.

CHOICE 1: We don't use plant genders, and separate Cactus in PvZ1 and PvZ2.

CHOICE 2: We use genders, keep Cactus together, and use the almanac gender. "It" or "They" will be used for plants with unknown almanac genders.

CHOICE 3: We use genders, keep Cactus together, and use only genders that are indisputable (barring things like Dandelion). "It" or "They" will be used for plants with ambiguous or unknown genders.

CHOICE 4: We don't use plant genders and keep Cactus together because ???

vote below 