Board Thread:Plants vs. Zombies Wiki discussion/@comment-3474455-20160125153454

Intro = This is a continuation of a previous thread about demoting poorly performing staff members, whose propose has been generally accepted by the community.

The first venue of discussion for us is about the list of poorly performing rollbacks who should be demoted. Although rollback is in theory at an equal level to chat moderators due to the new staff system enforced by Wikia, the position itself is usually regarded as the lowest tier in the staff ladder.

I have seen a few users in chat with questions about a rollback's power. Because of this, I feel the need to explain the powers of every staff power in its respective thread: Rollback is capable of reverting a chain of edits made by the last editor in a certain page, and erases all mentions of the activity on Special:WikiActivity. Although the Rollback right is designed to combat vandalism by reverting the damage quickly and covertly, its connection to the mainspace also means that the title holder is also obliged to make quality edits in normal times.

The list of suspects will be listed below. As this is a subject of great importance, careful and mature thinking will be expected for every vote. Because of this, all votes without a proper reason will be disqualified.

Suspect list=

SunShroom
Reason: Poor edit qualities, low activity. SunShroom mostly adds trivia to mainspace pages, most of which are usually removed by other staff members. His application for rollback is also rather controversial, as most of the supporter based their opinion on his artwork instead of his actual past performance, which is itself lacking.

Personal Comment: I do admire your work as an artist, but certainly could not say so about you as a wiki contributor. Maybe you should try to put more efforts in the future, since I also heard that you did try to follow the wiki.

Reapeageddon
Reason: Low mainspace activity; his last mainspace edit was on December 24th, almost a month away from the date of this thread.

Personal Comment: On the other hand, I believe that you have exceptional quality as a chat moderator, judging from your frequent activity and performance at chat logging. I suggest you apply for chat moderator instead after this is over.

ADVENT-UR-TRON
Reason: Low mainspace activity. He is the most active out of the three, but his activity still might not be sufficient enough for the task. Not much else can be stated however.  