Board Thread:General discussion/@comment-25083348-20160223014205/@comment-26593304-20160224142735

Foxtail Firepaw Flames wrote: Dung Dinh Anh wrote: Cattail, because zombie spam did not happen in PvZ1, meaning that a few of them plus Pumpkins can easily beat any pool/fog level. I think if we had something that did splash damage, and could take care of zombies that appeared during the low tide, we could have handled this.

Also, incase Popcap didn't realize, there actually was no zombie spam in PvZ1, which is why Lily Pads, and Tangle Kelp are insanely weak.

Banana Launcher is too expensive, but it's meh

Guacodile didn't do enough damage.

The zombies were TOO strong.

I think maybe Shadow Plants would've fit better there.

Back to PvZ1, A lot of the Water Stuff didn't have as much Zombie SPam or any at all, and having a Cattail just made it easier. ALso I think Cattail had a faster firing rate than Homing Thistle ;) ;) Cattail had a faster rate of fire, but if I'm right it did only 1 damage per spike. Homing Thistle does 2 damage per spike, so since Cattail shoots 2 spikes per volley then technically the two have the same DPS and rate of fire doesn't matter.